Wednesday, 12 October 2011

Goodwins' Theory


Goodwins' Theory



Andrew Goodwin had a theory, that, for a music video to be succesful it must include at least three of these following rules.



- There is a relationship between the lyrics and the visuals, with the visuals illustrating, amplifying or contradicting the lyrics. - This means exactly what you think it does, Goodwin believed that every music video should show a direct relationship between the lyrics and the video footage.



30 Seconds To Mars - This is War

if you ignore the cheesy clips of the lead singer aimlessly firing his gun in to the air, and the tanks 'n' shit that fall out of the sky, you can see that this music video shows perfectly what war is all about. It contains lots of clips of war situations, poltiticians, and freedom fighters. I think that, towards the end, the war vehicles that fly off and form the pyramid are there to portray peace. 


- There is a relationship between the music and the visuals, with the visuals illustrating, amplifying or contradicting the music. - The visuals in a video should always work parallel to the tempo and the beat. More often than not, the visuals help the music track to create a mood and and atmosphere.



The Horrible Crowes - Behold the Hurricane


This music video by The Horrible Crowes basically portrays a man who has lost everything. The lyrics help this theory along perfectly: "I remember everything we had. Every breath of this house creaking. I’m familiar with the cold and the windows and the doors.....I don’t recognize myself. I’m not the man you love." Watching the video and listening intently to the lyrics helps a lot with the understanding of this video, the actor wanders aimlessly with a bag of alcohol, feeling sorry for himself and sleeping on the streets.


- Genres are complex and diverse in terms of music video style and iconography - The genre of the music usually determines what kind of video will be made for it, for example, rock videos will mostly show ther band playing alongside a not-so-important parallel narrative, and a pop video will often show a few dancers with some kind of conceptual footage.



Lady Gaga - Judas

This video is a perfect example of an MV made for a pop song. It contains lots of dancing mixed in with a little bit of conceptual and and narrative based footage. The narrative of this video is a modern, unorthodox take on the stories of the bible.



- Record companies will demand a lot of close-ups of the main artist or vocalist - The reason behind doing this is to portray star image, so that the viewers know for a fact who the artist is. As with every band, the lead singer is always the most known and recognised, and i think this is partly because of the use of close-ups. Vocalists these days are often regarded as icons more than artists.



Jamie T - Sticks and Stones


This video follows the stereotypical antics of a teenager/young adult. The lyrics of the song coincide perfectly with the theme of troublemakers/miscreants/misfits; "When there's no one left to fight, boys like him don't shine so bright, soon as I see the dust settle, he's out on the town tryin' to find trouble."                     
- Voyeurism is present in many music videos, especially in the treatment of females, but also in terms of systems of looking. Some examples are screens within screens, cameras, mirrors, etc. - Voyeurism is the act of displaying women in a sexual light. In most music videos, especially rock, women are seen wearing very little clothing and dancing around provocatively.



Marilyn Manson - Tainted Love


- There are likely to be intertextual references, either to other music videos or to films and TV texts, these provide further gratification and pleasure for the viewers/fans. 




No comments:

Post a Comment